How to Tell Stories About Jesus That Spiritually Curious People Will Love
Author
Verlon Fosner
Date
July 20, 2026
Dinner Churches and other fresh expressions often gather people with little or no experience with church—or whose only experiences have been distant or disappointing. Many are spiritually curious but unfamiliar with Scripture, making the Bible feel confusing or inaccessible.
That's why we began looking for simple "entry points" into the story of what God is doing in the world.
When the early Church faced a similar challenge, they told stories about Jesus—His life, teachings, miracles, death, and resurrection. That's what the apostles proclaimed throughout the book of Acts. It's what they used for evangelism and discipleship. They trusted the stories of Jesus to introduce people to Jesus Himself.
Early church gatherings often happened around tables and shared meals. There, people heard simple, focused messages built around a single story from the life of Christ. Listeners were invited into Jesus' story, and over time, Jesus was invited into theirs.
These messages were usually brief. There's a reason for that. As Paul reminds us, "the gospel... is the power of God that brings salvation to everyone who believes" (Romans 1:16). The first apostles trusted the stories of Jesus to carry the weight of their preaching.
Creating a Bible for First-Time Readers
We wanted a Bible that worked naturally in the Dinner Church context—one centered on the stories of Jesus found in Matthew, Mark, Luke, John, and Acts. It would provide an accessible place for people to begin without overwhelming them with study notes, cross-references, or explanations intended for experienced Bible readers.
On a practical level, we also chose to remove the verse numbers. While helpful for study, they often interrupt the natural flow of the story and can feel unfamiliar to someone opening the Bible for the first time. We wanted readers to experience Scripture as a narrative that invites them in rather than as disconnected verses to analyze.
We partnered with the American Bible Society to create this resource using the Contemporary English Version (CEV). We retained simple story headings while allowing the text itself to remain uncluttered.
We called it Jesus Stories.
Many Bibles are designed with study in mind, complete with notes and cross-references that serve mature readers well. Jesus Stories serves a different purpose. It removes many of those barriers so first-time readers can simply encounter the life of Jesus. Every guest who joins one of our Dinner Churches receives a copy as a gift, and our pastors preach from it every week.
Why Stories Still Matter
In a culture saturated with opinions, arguments, and endless content, stories still have a unique ability to disarm us. Rather than telling people what they should believe, the stories of Jesus invite them to encounter Him for themselves.
Across our network of Dinner Churches, we've watched this simple practice awaken curiosity in people who never imagined church had anything to offer them. Week after week, guests tell us they find themselves thinking about the story long after dinner has ended.
Those of us in the household of faith know why. Jesus continues revealing Himself through His own story.
Over time, curiosity becomes conversation. Conversation becomes prayer. Prayer becomes a growing relationship with Christ.
Three Parts of the Jesus Story Experience
1. Storytelling
The speaker shares a seven-to-ten-minute message built around one story from the Gospels or Acts. Rather than offering a lengthy sermon, they read the passage and retell it in their own words, helping listeners enter the story naturally.
2. Personal Testimony
The storyteller then shares how that particular story has shaped their own life. Perhaps it brought peace during a difficult season, inspired courage to take a next step, or became a source of healing and hope. The goal is simply to show how Jesus continues to meet people today.
3. Reflection and Prayer
The gathering concludes by inviting everyone to reflect on what the story might be saying to them personally, followed by a generous prayer of blessing for those around the table.
Why We Keep Coming Back to the Stories of Jesus
We certainly teach from the whole of Scripture. Yet we intentionally allow the stories of Jesus to remain at the center of our preaching, discipleship, and evangelism. The rest of Scripture enriches and supports what we first discover in Christ Himself.
More than ever, people are looking for authentic conversations about faith rather than polished presentations. Two thousand years later, the stories of Jesus are still introducing people to Jesus.
We hope more churches and fresh expressions will rediscover the simple power of sharing His story.
-------------------------------------------------------------
Putting It Into Practice: Telling a Jesus Story
You don't need to be a preacher or Bible teacher to tell a Jesus story well. You simply need to know the story, allow it to shape you, and be willing to share it naturally with others.
Step 1: Let the Story Get Inside You
Choose a story from the Gospels. Start with a shorter passage, then work your way toward longer ones as you become more comfortable.
Read the story several times—silently and aloud. Better yet, invite someone else to read it with you. As you become familiar with the story, reflect on these questions:
- What do I love about this story?
- What surprises or challenges me?
- What does this story reveal about God?
- What does it reveal about people?
- What invitation is Jesus extending to me?
- What will I do with this story—share it, apply it, or continue reflecting on it?
Step 2: Let the Story Shape You
As you spend time with the story, pay attention to how it is affecting you.
Ask yourself:
- How does this story make me feel?
- Where is the tension or conflict?
- Which character do I most identify with?
- What details stand out to me or connect with my community?
- What questions does this story leave me with?
- Is Jesus inviting me to think differently, act differently, or trust Him more?
- Does this story make me think of someone I should share it with?
Step 3: Let the Story Flow Through You
Practice telling the story to someone else.
Don't worry about memorizing every detail or trying to sound like a preacher. Simply tell the story in your own words while staying faithful to what Scripture says.
As you prepare, consider:
- What is the main point I want people to notice?
- Which details help communicate that point?
- How would I naturally tell this story around a dinner table, over coffee, or in an everyday conversation?
- Am I telling it in a way that is understandable, accurate, and engaging?
- How might I encourage someone else to share this story with another person?
Afterward, take a few minutes to reflect. What happened? What surprised you? If possible, invite your listener to respond to the questions from Steps 1 and 2. You may discover that God is already at work in ways you never expected.

About the Author
Verlon Fosner
Verlon and Melodee Fosner have spent more than four decades helping churches reimagine mission. While leading a century-old church in Seattle, they pioneered the Dinner Church model, discovering that gathering around shared meals created natural opportunities for people to encounter Jesus. Since joining Fresh Expressions in 2016, they have helped equip leaders across North America, contributing to the launch of more than 1,000 Dinner Churches.












