Jeanette Staats • August 12, 2024

When God Sends You Somewhere Else with Dan Altimus

Listen

Watch

Show Notes

Dan had a plan for planting in an exciting city, but through a series of nudges, they ended up in a small town with a significant drug problem. In this fascinating interview, you’ll hear how they attracted one-sixth of their town to their Dinner Church. You’ll also hear about why they stayed after the COVID pandemic shut down their congregation, and what their ministry looks like today.


Daniel Altimus is the pastor of Common Ground Church in York Haven, Pennsylvania. Never imagining himself as a church planter, God connected Daniel to two other men with a love for the gospel and a heart to see people discipled. After a period of sowing the gospel for three years in York Haven, they planted Common Ground Dinner Church in September of 2017. Daniel lives in York Haven with his wife Angie. They have two adult sons, Luke and Shane. 



Related Resources:

Dinner Church Collective (Facebook Page)

Email us: podcasts@freshexpressions.com



Subscribe & Review

Help us get the word out by subscribing and leaving a review for Rural Renewal Podcast on your favorite platform.

Apple Podcasts
Spotify
Google Podcasts

Interview Summary

“Let’s just say it took us out of our comfort zones in a different way…” – Dan Altimus

This poignant reflection by Dan Altimus, a key figure in the Dinner Church movement in Yorkhaven, Pennsylvania, captures the transformative journey many have experienced. In this detailed exploration of this Dinner Church podcast episode with Dan Altimus, we delve into the innovative model of Dinner Church—a place where food, faith, and community intertwine to rejuvenate not only individual lives but entire communities.


Dan Altimus, alongside his wife Angela, leads a significant community effort in New York Haven through the Dinner Church Collective. With roots deeply embedded in the community, Dan’s ministry focuses on revitalizing the local area through the ancient practice of gathering around the dinner table—turning a simple meal into a profound communal experience.


The Essence of Dinner Church: More Than Just a Meal

A Rebirth from Decline

The Dinner Church model was born out of a response to a period of unexplained decline within Dan Altimus’s community. This decline prompted the community leaders to seek new, impactful ways to engage and uplift their surroundings. The transition to a Dinner Church wasn’t merely about changing the mode of worship or community gathering; it was about responding to a deep, communal need for connection and revitalization. By embedding the church within the routine act of sharing meals, they tapped into a longstanding tradition that promotes fellowship and unity, thus revitalizing the community’s spirit and engagement.

“And 20 years ago, our church went into an unexplainable decline. much frustration that soon led to much prayer. and we really felt the Lord direct us to begin to experiment with this ancient form of church, the table church, if you will.” – Dan Altimus

Core Principles of Engagement

Dinner Church is built on principles that emphasize simplicity, affordability, and evangelistic effectiveness, making it a potent tool for community outreach across various demographics and locations. This model strips back the often complex and resource-heavy structures of traditional churches, opting instead for a more accessible and relatable format. Meals serve as a universal invitation into community life, breaking down barriers and fostering an environment where people can engage in spiritual discussions in a relaxed and welcoming setting. These principles ensure that Dinner Churches can be easily replicated and adapted across different contexts, making them versatile and inclusive.

“Dinner churches are affordable. They are simple. They are very effective at evangelism. And they are rapidly increasing across the country and across all denominational lines and across all social locations.” – Verlon Fosner

Impactful Outreach

The transformative impact of Dinner Church is vividly seen in the personal stories of community members who find not just physical nourishment but also emotional and spiritual support. The inclusive setting allows people who might not typically step into a traditional church setting to feel welcomed. This approach significantly shifts how outreach is conducted, focusing on serving and building the community from within rather than merely preaching to them. It’s about active engagement—meeting people where they are, addressing real needs, and providing a platform for genuine transformation and connection.

“And one of the gentlemen there that was leading that conference, he handed me a book called welcome to Dinner Church … I read probably a chapter of that book, and it was like, instantly I knew this is this was the answer… They read just a little bit and they were like, yes, this is this is where God wants us to go.” – Dan Altimus

As we reflect on the conversation with Dan, it becomes evident that Dinner Church is more than a feeding program; it’s a catalyst for community transformation. By fostering an environment of acceptance and support, Dinner Church empowers individuals to partake in a shared vision of growth and development.


Reflection Questions

  1. What makes the concept of Dinner Church appealing to communities facing social challenges?
  2. How does sharing a meal facilitate deeper connections among community members?
  3. How can individuals contribute to the sustainability of such community initiatives?
  4. What are the long-term impacts of such a community-focused approach on local development?
  5. How does the concept of Dinner Church challenge traditional perceptions of church and community service?

Share

People gathered around a table for a meal, indoors.

Discipleship Reset Replay

A FREE training experience designed to equip leaders.

By Jeanette Staats December 15, 2025
What happens when faith is formed through creativity, curiosity, and hands-on participation rather than rows and sermons? In this episode, Heather sits down with Crystal Goetz to explore the shared heartbeat between Messy Church and Fresh Expressions. Together they unpack how intergenerational, creative, and hands-on spaces cultivate openness, curiosity, and connection—often in places far beyond a traditional sanctuary. Crystal shares surprising stories of discipleship that unfolds across generations and reflects on how participatory, experiential communities naturally invite people into belonging from the very beginning. Crystal Goetz is a session writer, ambassador, and trainer for Messy Church USA, bringing her long-time experience as a Family Ministries Director into creating inclusive content and launching Messy Churches in unconventional community spaces. When she’s not immersed in all things Messy Church, she enjoys making junk journals and reclaimed paper ephemera, watching English football with a cup of tea, and traveling or playing games with her family. Crystal often says, “Messy Church is my church,” finding deep meaning in its interactive, inquisitive nature and dedicating herself to helping Messy Churches grow and thrive for years to come. This season, we’re diving into the streams of Fresh Expressions — from senior adults and recovery ministry, to arts, outdoors, recreation, and more. Each month, you’ll hear directly from practitioners who are navigating these fresh ways of being church in the world. Their stories will spark your imagination and encourage you to see where God is already at work in your community and how you might join in! So whether you’re a pastor, lay leader, or simply curious about how church can thrive beyond the walls, join us for Season seven of the Fresh Expressions Podcast. Related Resources:
By Jeanette Staats December 8, 2025
In this episode of the Rural Renewal Podcast, we talk with Nanc Bourne and Malcolm Fowler about how a simple nudge from God grew into monthly community dinners that meet a real need in their rural town. What began with a few faithful people has become a lay-led ministry that’s strengthening relationships, feeding neighbors, and renewing the church’s mission. Their story shows how small steps—led by ordinary church members, not just pastors—can bear real fruit. If you’re longing to see your community thrive, this conversation offers hope and practical inspiration for what God can spark right where you are. Malcolm Fowler is the pastor at Calvary Baptist Church in Springfield, VT since 2016. He is called to serve with the love of Jesus for the people of Jesus. A native New Englander he loves all things motorcycling, all things Scottish, Tolkien, his family, his Church, and his Savior, not necessarily in that order. In ministry Malcolm loves to see people grow in the depth of their relationship with Jesus. Nanc Bourne is a recently retired registered nurse. She is joyously engaged in ministry at the Calvary Baptist fellowship Related Resources: Join our Facebook group: Rural Renewal Podcast Community Email us: podcasts@freshexpressions.com Subscribe & Review Help us get the word out by subscribing and leaving a review for Rural Renewal Podcast on your favorite platform. Apple Podcasts Spotify Google Podcasts
By Jeanette Staats November 24, 2025
In this episode of the Rural Renewal Podcast, we talk with Nanc Bourne and Malcolm Fowler about how a simple nudge from God grew into monthly community dinners that meet a real need in their rural town. What began with a few faithful people has become a lay-led ministry that’s strengthening relationships, feeding neighbors, and renewing the church’s mission. Their story shows how small steps—led by ordinary church members, not just pastors—can bear real fruit. If you’re longing to see your community thrive, this conversation offers hope and practical inspiration for what God can spark right where you are. Malcolm Fowler is the pastor at Calvary Baptist Church in Springfield, VT since 2016. He is called to serve with the love of Jesus for the people of Jesus. A native New Englander he loves all things motorcycling, all things Scottish, Tolkien, his family, his Church, and his Savior, not necessarily in that order. In ministry Malcolm loves to see people grow in the depth of their relationship with Jesus. Nanc Bourne is a recently retired registered nurse. She is joyously engaged in ministry at the Calvary Baptist fellowship Related Resources: Join our Facebook group: Rural Renewal Podcast Community Email us: podcasts@freshexpressions.com Subscribe & Review Help us get the word out by subscribing and leaving a review for Rural Renewal Podcast on your favorite platform. Apple Podcasts Spotify Google Podcasts
By Jeanette Staats October 20, 2025
Marta never imagined she’d live in Mississippi—much less start a church. But God had other plans. In this episode, hear how Marta’s love for her Hispanic community and passion for teaching became the spark for a new kind of church—one that began not in a sanctuary, but in a local library and around shared meals. As she gathered with children and families to read books in their language, moments of storytime and food became sacred opportunities to build relationships, nurture belonging, and share the love of Jesus. Discover how something as simple as gathering over a table or opening a book can become the foundation for a vibrant faith community—a beautiful fresh expression of church rooted in familia, hospitality, and hope. Marta Sobrino Bolen , the pastor of Glenfield United Methodist Church, has started a ministry for Latinos called La Misión that helps Latino families in three areas: family, community, and spiritual growth. La Misión currently includes a tutoring program, a food pantry, a clothes pantry, reading and writing skills, spiritual growth, and support to families who have just arrived to the US. Related Resources: Fresh Expressions Incubator - Dinner Church in Hispanic Communities (November 5th) Email us: podcasts@freshexpressions.com Subscribe & Review Help us get the word out by subscribing and leaving a review for Rural Renewal Podcast on your favorite platform. Apple Podcasts Spotify Google Podcasts
By Jeanette Staats October 13, 2025
What happens when a h eart for missions meets the quiet rhythms of rural life? In this episode of the Rural Renewal Podcast, we sit down with Tim Schwartz, a Pennsylvania pastor whose calling to short-term mission work has led him into all kinds of disaster relief efforts across the country. Tim shares how serving in places of crisis has reshaped his understanding of ministry and the local church. Now serving in a rural setting, Tim opens up about adjusting to small-town life—and how simple acts, like gathering with men for breakfast every week, have become spaces for real connection and transformation. Tim Schwartz lives in Cogan Station, PA with his wife, Jenn, and three children. He pastors Hepburn Baptist Church and works as the North Central PA Geographic Pastoral Servant for ABCOPAD. He received his Bachelor’s degree in Chemistry at James Madison University and his Master of Divinity from Eastern Baptist Theological Seminary. Throughout his last 25 years of ministry, Tim has pastored churches, worked as an interim minister, and facilitated numerous mission trips in disaster recovery. Tim is an avid Philadelphia sports fan, well-experienced youth sports coach, cancer survivor, and enjoys chatting with people over lunch or coffee. Related Resources: Join our Facebook group: Rural Renewal Podcast Community Email us: podcasts@freshexpressions.com Subscribe & Review Help us get the word out by subscribing and leaving a review for Rural Renewal Podcast on your favorite platform. Apple Podcasts Spotify Google Podcasts
By Jeanette Staats October 5, 2025
In this bonus episode, we sit down with Dr. Mike Graves, author of Table Talk and plenary speaker for the Dinner Church Summit 2025 in Pittsburgh (Nov 6–8). He shares the personal story behind his ministry—childhood roots, encounters with Jesus, and the life messages God has entrusted to him. We also get a preview of what excites him about the Table and why it remains one of the most transformative spaces for the Gospel today. Register now for the Dinner Church Summit at freshexpressions.com/dinner-church-summit-2025 Mike Graves is Scholar in Residence at Country Club Christian Church in Kansas City, Missouri. Before retiring from teaching, he was the Wm. K. McElvaney Professor of Preaching and Worship at Saint Paul School of Theology, also in Kansas City. His most recent book is Table Talk: Rethinking Communion and Community. Related Resources: Email us: podcasts@freshexpressions.com Subscribe & Review Help us get the word out by subscribing and leaving a review for Rural Renewal Podcast on your favorite platform. Apple Podcasts Spotify Google Podcasts
By Jeanette Staats September 29, 2025
What does it look like to build a vibrant Christian community in a senior living center—one of the loneliest places in our culture? In this episode, we sit down with Jon Moody, leader of Park Place Community in Fort Wayne, Indiana, to hear how a Fresh Expression of Church is reshaping life in senior living. From vulnerability and loneliness to newfound belonging and faith, Jon shares the surprising blessings of starting this ministry—and the simple practices of showing up and listening that make all the difference. Park Place Community is more than a program; it’s changing culture, creating connection, and showing that even later in life, people are finding their place at the table with Jesus. Whether you serve seniors, lead in ministry, or simply care about belonging, this story will inspire you to imagine what’s possible when the church shows up in unexpected places. This season, we’re diving into the streams of Fresh Expressions — from senior adults and recovery ministry, to arts, outdoors, recreation, and more. Each month, you’ll hear directly from practitioners who are navigating these fresh ways of being church in the world. Their stories will spark your imagination and encourage you to see where God is already at work in your community and how you might join in! So whether you’re a pastor, lay leader, or simply curious about how church can thrive beyond the walls, join us for Season seven of the Fresh Expressions Podcast. Related Resources:
Two men in gold circles; one with a beard and blue shirt, the other with short hair.
September 26, 2025
Ministry in rural areas can have challenges, when it comes to resources. Listen to Marta share how she has addressed the needs of Latino community (especially with language barriers) in her town and advocate for them and how she has partnered with schools, libraries, and other organizations to connect with people in her community. Marta Sobrino Bolen, the pastor of Glenfield United Methodist Church, has started a ministry for Latinos called La Misión that helps Latino families in three areas: family, community, and spiritual growth. La Misión currently includes a tutoring program, a food pantry, a clothes pantry, reading and writing skills, spiritual growth, and support to families who have just arrived to the US. Related Resources: Glenfield UMC Facebook page Join our Facebook group: Rural Renewal Podcast Community Email us: podcasts@freshexpressions.com Subscribe & Review Help us get the word out by subscribing and leaving a review for Rural Renewal Podcast on your favorite platform. Apple Podcasts Spotify Google Podcasts
Smiling bald man with a beard, in a blue shirt, inside a yellow circle, against a light yellow farm background.
August 18, 2025
Retired pastor and ministry coach Dave Peppler shares lessons from over 20 years in rural ministry, from guiding a congregation through closure to helping churches rediscover their unique calling. He offers practical insights on pastoral health, the value of bi-vocational ministry, and trusting that the God who calls is always sufficient to equip. Dave Peppler is a retired pastor with more than 22 years of ministry in North Carolina and Virginia. He holds advanced degrees in spirituality, Christian education, leadership, and theology. The author of Healthy Endings: A Leader’s Journey Through a Church Legacy Transition , he now serves as a spirituality coach, retreat leader, church consultant, and Christian leadership coach, helping individuals and faith communities discover and live out their unique calling in Christ. Help us spread the word about the Rural Renewal podcast by subscribing and leaving us reviews on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, YouTube or wherever you enjoy your podcasts. Related Resources: The Still Small Voice in the Deer Stand – Christianity Today HOME | Peptalk Ministries Join our Facebook group: Rural Renewal Podcast Community Email us: podcasts@freshexpressions.com
Man smiling, wearing glasses and a maroon hoodie. Illustration of people at a table.
By Jeanette Staats August 4, 2025
Listen
Show More